Determining Fault In A Truck Accident

Determining Fault in Truck Accident

Truck accidents are some of the most dangerous accidents on our nation’s highways.  An 80,000-pound truck traveling at 55 mph is a force.  Sadly, most cars are no match for 18-wheelers in a collision.  Fortunately, many truck companies operate their commercial vehicles safely.  However, there are a few companies that operate their trucks negligently by failing to adhere to the federal truck safety regulations as well as failing to attain proper truck inspections.  A poorly operated commercial vehicle puts lives at risk on the road.  When the unfortunate event of a truck accident occurs, there comes a time when determining who is at fault for the cause of the truck accident must be made.  This is when you need an experienced truck accident attorney to assist and protect you in determining fault in a truck accident.  Walker Texas Lawyer is Houston’s Truck Accident Attorney who will be by your side.

Who Is at Fault in A Truck Accident?

When trucks collide with other vehicles, there are several parties that could be at fault.  The other vehicle, the truck driver, the truck company, the truck manufacturer or the manufacture of a part may all be at fault.  The police, insurance companies, attorneys, state and federal investigators will all be looking at several factors, some of which are listed below, in determining fault in truck accidents:

Some Causes Of Truck Accidents

  • Negligence
  • Driver fatigue
  • Driver impairment
  • Part Failure
  • Bad Hiring Practices
  • Failure to provide maintenance
  • Third party causes
  • Improper loads
  • Failure to follow truck regulations
Determining Fault In A Car Accident - Truck Accident Lawyer

One of the most crucial elements in determining fault in a truck accident is negligence. Often in court, attorneys or insurance companies will use the concept of negligence. They are also known as the driver’s failure to exercise “duty of care” to prove whichever driver was more careless. The initial police report and other citations often determine negligence. However, eyewitness statements can play a significant factor as well. To determine negligence, we must understand the three negligence laws.

Pure Contributory Negligence

The idea behind pure contributory negligence is that if one driver contributed even slightly to a collision, they could not recover damages. Additionally, they are considered at fault. However, the rule can be disputed if the plaintiff proves that the defendant was willfully destructive or knowingly negligent.  Contributory negligence is tough to get around since it requires virtually total innocence on the part of the plaintiff; only a handful of states utilize this rule.

Pure Comparative Fault

Pure comparative fault means that fault can be divided between two drivers. The idea here is that the plaintiff can only sue for that portion of damages arising from the accident for which the plaintiff is not at fault.  Even if the plaintiff is 99% at fault, damages would be calculated by subtracting the percentage of the plaintiff’s fault from the total damages awarded.

Modified Comparative Fault

Modified comparative fault is the same rule are pure comparative fault, except that it bars plaintiffs from suing for damages when they are more than 50% at fault (or 51%, depending on the laws of the state where the accident occurred).

Is A Police Report What Determines Fault?

The simple answer is NO. While the police report may provide some evidence, it is not the final authority on who is at fault in the accident.  As you can see from above, there can be many contributing factors to a truck accident case.  Additionally, the officer on the scene may not be fully trained in providing an expert truck accident report.  This is why hiring an attorney that understands truck accident investigations is essential.  In doing this, your attorney will follow up with eyewitnesses, dig into the truck’s maintenance records, hire experts to review the crash, and much more.

Trucking Companies and Manufacturers Can Be Held Liable

Trucking companies are required by federal law to follow  Federal trucking regulations.  This imposes a series of rules alongside truck inspections that they must follow. If the truck company fails to provide proper maintenance or hiring practices, they could be liable for your accident. The manufacturer might be responsible if the truck itself was poorly designed or flawed. The list of parties responsible for the safe design, manufacture, maintenance, and operation of commercial trucks is long. If negligence occurs anywhere in the chain of responsibility for truck safety, the culpable parties can and should be held accountable.

Here is a link to the Federal Trucking  Regulations posted by FMCSA

Why choose Walker Texas Lawyer – Houston’s Truck Accident Attorney

Walker Texas Lawyer is an experienced truck accident attorney. He has handled many truck accident cases and knows how to work with insurance companies and the legal system to provide you with the compensation you deserve. At Walker Texas Lawyer, our first concern is that you are safe if you are in a trucking accident. Once you are safe, we will listen to you and your accident memories. Also, James Walker will work to help you with the losses you have suffered. Losses such as pain and suffering, lost wages, and property damage.

We Will Help In Determining the Fault In A Truck Accident

Trucking companies are held to high standards of safety. We will perform a full truck accident investigation.  Our goal is to determine if all the rules and regulations were met.  Was the employer or truck driver negligent?  Was there a failure of a part or parts on the truck? We will talk with witnesses. Additionally, Walker will reconstruct the accident and bring in experts to examine all aspects of the accident. Furthermore, he will check maintenance logs, driver logs, safety inspections, GPS records, and truck accident reports.

We will handle all insurance claims for you.

The insurance company and trucking company will have lawyers on their side. It would be best if you had an experienced truck accident attorney. Insurance companies may act like your friend, but they are not in the business of paying out. It would be best if you had an experienced truck accident attorney to represent you in fighting them.
If you or a loved one has been involved in an accident involving a truck, call Walker Texas Lawyer.  He is the Houston Truck Accident Attorney.  Call today at 713- 552-1117


(713) 552-1117


Truck Accident Resources

Do Commercial Truck Drivers Take A Drug Test After an Accident?

When navigating the aftermath of a trucking accident in Texas, understanding the regulatory landscape surrounding drug and alcohol testing for commercial truck drivers is crucial. The immense size and momentum of an 18-wheeler make any accident potentially...

Should I Accept An Insurance Settlement?

In the aftermath of an accident, dealing with insurance companies and settlements can be an overwhelming process. You might find yourself tempted to accept the initial settlement offer from your insurance company, just to move on and put the incident behind you....

Houston Hit and Run Accidents: A Comprehensive Guide

Getting into a car accident is always disconcerting, but the experience can be particularly unnerving if it involves a hit-and-run. Amid the sudden shock and possible injuries, the driver who should be held responsible just vanishes, leaving behind a cascade of...

Commercial Truck Accident Statistics

Did you realize that Texas, the Lone Star State, boasts the largest number of lane miles in the entire United States? Furthermore, four out of the top eight American cities with the greatest lane mileage per person are located within our state's borders. Considering...

Who is At Fault in a T-Bone Accident: Understanding Liability

T-bone accidents, also known as side-impact collisions, can result in severe injuries and significant medical bills. When one vehicle collides with the side of another at a 90-degree angle, the impact can be devastating. Many people assume that the driver who hits the...

Tire Failure Attorney James Walker

Automobile Tire Failure Accidents Tire Failure Attorney James Walker shares his thoughts on potential driving hazards. Known for its heat, Houston has experienced surprisingly cool weather this spring, but don't let that fool you. All Houstonians know that summer is...

I Have Been In An Accident In A Company Car, What Should I Do?

Being involved in an accident is a traumatic experience, and it becomes particularly complicated if the accident occurs while driving a company car. Not only do you need to handle the physical and emotional aftermath, but you also have to navigate the legal and...

18-Wheeler Underride Accidents in Texas & How to Recover Damages

18-Wheeler underride accidents are among the most severe truck accidents, often resulting in catastrophic injuries or fatalities. If you have been involved in a truck underride accident in Texas, seeking legal representation from a skilled attorney who can assist you...

Not only does he put his full heart into everything that he does but he also fights very hard for the right cause and gets you what you deserve. He fights hard and tough but also stays extremely honest and so very kind to all of his clients. I’ve never met anyone in my life, a more motivated, strategic, go-getter lawyer than Walker. He changed my whole world with what he did for my family. We would have never been able to get the justice that was needed without him. I could never in my life thank him enough for what he did for my family. If you want someone strong willed, a fighter, and someone that goes above and beyond for justice and his clients…then you have found the right Law firm. I wish I could give a million stars cause 5 just isn’t enough. If you need to ask me about my experience personally feel free to message me. He never gave up on me….and I thank him beyond words.

Bri Heath

Practice Areas

Our Offices


Walker Texas Lawyer - (Principal Office)

3100 Timmons Ln Suite 401
Houston, Tx 77027


Call: (713) 552-1117

Houston - Montrose Location

Walker Texas Lawyer - (Montrose Location)

2238 Richmond Avenue
Houston, Tx 77098


Call: (713) 280-7985


Walker Texas Lawyer - (Pasadena Office)

4008 Vista Rd Suite 202A
Pasadena, TX 77504


Call: (281) 545-5158

Texas City

Walker Texas Lawyer Arena

9300 Emmett F. Lowry Expressway
Texas City, Tx 77591


Call: (713) 331-6848

Related Blog Articles

Associations & Awards